Is Your Marketing Working? Take the 45-Second Marketing Check
Most of the time, marketing that isn't working has a plan problem, not a budget problem. Research, strategy, measurement or ownership is missing, and more spend just makes the same plan problem bigger. Answer eight questions to see which one to fix first. It takes about 45 seconds, and your result shows right here.
Why Check Before You Spend More?
You're not the only owner asking whether marketing is working. Effort and spend are up, and confidence is down.
80%
of business leaders rate their marketing at best "somewhat" effective.
27% to 18%
The share of small businesses "very confident" in their marketing fell from 27% to 18%.
Source: Constant Contact, 2025
Take the 45-Second Marketing Check
Answer Yes, Sort of or No to each question. Be honest. Nobody's grading this but you.
Research · Question 1 of 8
Can I describe my target customer and why they buy, in two sentences?
Research · Question 2 of 8
Was there real, deep research behind my current marketing plan?
Strategy · Question 3 of 8
Can I state my marketing strategy in one or two sentences without listing tactics?
Strategy · Question 4 of 8
Has my strategy held steady long enough to judge it, even if tactics changed?
Strategy · Question 5 of 8
Has the strategy identified the key outcomes desired and aligned them with the tactics outlined in it?
Measurement · Question 6 of 8
Does my monthly report start with business outcomes in mind, not activity?
Measurement · Question 7 of 8
Did we agree on what "working" means before we started spending and executing?
Ownership · Question 8 of 8
Is one named person or team accountable for marketing results?
0 of 8 answered
Your scorecard shows exactly how to fix it, step by step.
Know an owner who should run this check?
How the Check Is Scored
Each answer earns points: Yes is 2, Sort of is 1 and No is 0. Your total is out of 16.
- 14 to 16: Your plan is solid. Execution is the likelier issue, followed by budget allocation adjustments.
- 8 to 13: Your plan has gaps to fix before you spend more.
- 0 to 7: The problem is the plan.
The Four Areas
Questions 1 and 2 are Research. Questions 3 to 5 are Strategy. Questions 6 and 7 are Measurement. Question 8 is Ownership. Each area shows as strong, shaky or missing, and your result tells you where to start. Research comes first on a tie, because everything else depends on it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is the Before You Spend Check?
It's eight questions that show whether your marketing problem is the plan or the budget. It takes about 45 seconds. The first seven come from Robert Caruso's article "Why Is My Marketing Not Working? 7 Signs the Problem Isn't Your Budget."
What Does a High or Low Score Mean?
The higher your score, the stronger your plan. A score of 14 or more suggests execution is the likelier issue, followed by budget allocation adjustments. A lower score means fix the plan before you add spend.
What Do the Four Areas Mean?
Questions 1 and 2 cover research, questions 3 to 5 cover strategy, questions 6 and 7 cover measurement, and question 8 covers ownership. Each area shows as strong, shaky or missing. Start with the weakest area. On a tie, research comes first, because everything else depends on it.
Do I Have to Give My Email to See My Result?
No. Your score, your four area labels and where to start show on this page as soon as you answer all eight questions. The step-by-step fixes come in your one-page scorecard. Enter your first name and email to get it, and you'll also join the Engage waitlist with early access for launch.
Is My Marketing Problem the Budget or the Plan?
A budget problem is a sound plan that can't reach enough of the right prospects because it's underfunded. A plan problem is money being spent without proper research, a clear strategy, measurement against business goals, or the right owner of the outcome. It's a plan problem far more often than a budget problem.
About the Author
Robert Caruso is the founder and CEO of Engage Digital Inc. and a former marketing agency CEO. He writes about why marketing stalls and what it takes to fix it: research, strategy, measurement and ownership. Read his article Why Is My Marketing Not Working?
Engage Digital is the AI-powered marketing department we're building to turn your budget into results. Coming early 2027. When Engage launches, there are no contracts and no hidden fees. Just marketing that works every day to improve your results.